Ex-health secretary stops short of recommending immediate cut to national insurance 

Screenshot 2026-11-17 123003

Alan Milburn speaking at Google this morning

Alan Milburn has published his long-awaited review into youth economic inactivity, setting out proposals for new statutory entitlements to support for young people, alongside radical reforms to welfare and cash incentives for employers.

The former health secretary was commissioned by government to undertake the review into how the rising rate of young people not in employment, education or trainings - so called Neets - can be reversed.

His findings, hotly anticipated since his interim report in May, were published this morning, setting out a proposed 10-year programme which aims to “change the life course of nearly one million young people who are not currently in education, employment or training”.

Launching the report at Google’s offices in London, Milburn stressed that there was “nothing […] remotely compassionate or indeed progressive about leaving a 19-year-old on a path towards a lifetime of economic inactivity.” 

“That is what the current system does, and that is what we have to change,” he said.

Milburn, who held cabinet positions in the New Labour government at the turn of the century, said made the case for greater state involvement in the youth unemployment problem, noting that the only entitlement the state gives to most young people is “the entitlement to a benefit”.

He urged the government to change this by introducing a statutory entitlement to a route into education or employment, a new support guarantee to give them the practical help they need to the opportunity it up, and a third legally-enshrined guarantee to backstop the system.

Under the last of these, the government would guarantee a six-month paid role to a young person who has been out of work for a year.

The 278-page report described the country as being at a “fork in the road” which requires “difficult changes”, setting out a five-fold strategy, devoting a chapter each to the youth labour market, the education system, care and health services, welfare, and state support for job opportunities.

The measures set out in ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State’ include cash incentives for employers to take on Neets. Someone inactive for six months might come with a £3,000 payment, while £2,000 could be offered if the young person has been in care or is disabled.

“On the minimum wage, the government should continue to direct the Low Pay Commission to judge the pace of convergence against the critical goal of protecting youth employment in what is a very fragile labour market,” he said.

However, he said an immediate across-the-board national insurance cut was ”not the best use of £5bn worth of public money”, instead urging ”a five-year glide path to lower employer national insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24, starting in the retail and hospitality sectors”.

Milburn also proposed an aim to double the number of people completing apprenticeships by 2036 and recommended an expansion of post-18 college places. 

He suggested an extra 150,000 18- to 24-year-olds should take up a further education place and that regional mayors should work with local employers to develop industry-led technical colleges.

Perhaps more controversially for the Labour government the report is addressed to, Milburn recommended major reforms to the welfare system.

Under his proposed system, under-25s would no longer qualify for Universal Credit, while Pip, which supports people with extra costs associated with disability, would be scrapped.

Instead, young people would receive a Youth Allowance at the base level, while disability support would be provided through two funds, one for ongoing costs and the other for on-off expenses.

Milburn also proposed the creation of a new Youth Opportunity Service in every part of England. This, he said this would be “a local front door through which all these services can be properly and more efficiently coordinated”. 

This would provide “one place to go for the young person and the employer, for help with pastoral support for a small business taking on a young worker, for arranging work experience, for getting careers advice, for sorting out benefits, and for delivering the opportunity and support guarantees for the young person”. 

Young people would have a single named adviser, a single plan built around them and a single system that “stays with them until they’re securely learning or earning”.

“I believe we should set ourselves a new national ambition: every young person should be learning, earning or actively participating,” Milburn wrote in his report. 

He said the UK should aim to reduce the Neet rate to around 5% by 2036, with the first milestone being the elimination of 16- to 17-year-olds Neets. 57,000 currently are currently in the latter position, with thousands more recorded as not known.

The review claims that higher youth participation could contribute over 0.4% of additional GDP per year and reduce benefit expenditure by £3.6 billion per annum in 2036.

However, to make full youth participation possible, the review’s modelling suggests that 500,000 additional employment and education opportunities may be needed by 2036.

To support the plan, he called on the government to provide an initial investment of at least £500m, available from April next year.

Topics