Report comment

Lord Bruce-Brainfreeze can drivel on all he likes about Robin Hood Gardens. 'Love it or loathe it, this one does not make the grade...' Who does he think he is - Simon Cowell? It is depressing because in the end this is a judgement about who we are. English Heritage has decided that we don't like the look of it, that we think it wasn't as innovative as Park Hill and that the Smithsons were mere theorists anyway. It's been years since I read the architects' original proposals for Robin Hood, but I remember their warmth...the brief criteria included stuff like ' where will November 5 be celebrated?' Robin Hood is a living, if moribund, link to a more optimistic sense of social justice. Public sector rented housing, however well-intentioned, must now be expunged from our memory, so it doesn't tweak our conscience. If it's broke, don't fix it. English Heritage can say what it likes, but not in my f***ing name.