Wednesday23 August 2017

This Stirling shortlist favours the safe and generic

  • Email
  • Comments (7)
  • Save

The usual suspects are once again honoured at the expense of truly stirring architecture.

This year’s Stirling Prize shortlist will be greeted with a great collective yawn - followed by a startled cry.

The yawn is prompted by seeing the same old names trotted out once again - David Chipperfield, Zaha Hadid, AHMM - the ensuing shock from the realisation that the buildings representing them here are clearly not their finest.

Hadid has made a worthy inclusion in the past, but the Evelyn Grace Academy, Brixton, is possibly her clunkiest work to date, a monumental shed with appliquéd parametric styling and the aggressive swagger of a power yacht. Is this really the time to be celebrating a hedge-fund-sponsored fortress, as the government is systematically dismantling any hope for the future of educational buildings? Surely Sarah Wigglesworth’s Sandal Magna School in Wakefield would have made a more worthy contender.

Bennetts Associates’ Royal Shakespeare Theatre in Stratford boasts an excellent auditorium by all accounts, but from the outside it looks like an out-of-town multiplex crossed with a prisoner of war camp. Must buildings that work well also be so ugly?

AHMM’s Angel building in London and Chipperfield’s Folkwang may be objectively hard to fault - the Angel is topical, demonstrating an accomplished reinvention of an existing building, while the Essen museum is Chippo on fine autopilot - but neither truly stir the soul.

It seems the Stirling Prize has become about paying lip service to the safe and generic, rather than celebrating the truly innovative or joyful. Where is the fun of MVRDV’s Balancing Barn, or the drama of Foster & Partners’ Faustino winery, or the experimental ingenuity of David Lea and Pat Borer’s Wise building?

The only real contenders for me are O’Donnell & Tuomey’s An Gaeláras and Hopkins’ Olympic Velodrome - one a beautifully crafted series of social spaces, the other a perfectly distilled marriage of architect and engineer.

My money is on the Velodrome - for political as well as architectural reasons - leaving the understated Dubliners to pick up the gong next year for their outstanding Lyric theatre.


Readers' comments (7)

  • Vinesh Pomal

    I would go for either the O’Donnell & Tuomey’s An Gaeláras or the Hopkins’ Olympic Velodrome.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Are Architects ever happy...? In this age of austerity the professional continues to ask itself far too many superficial questions?

    Hadid's school "clunky" - well perhaps, but the fact that she is building a school in the first place is perhaps more a statement.

    The gallery in Londonderry wins it for me, however.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • *cough cough* Derry Samuel, Derry!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The Evelyn Grace Academy looks good in photographs but I understand is not so successful on the inside. Great to have a school to round out the generic, but this is the wrong one!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Simon  Quinlank

    They're all rotten buildings, each and everyone of them. Plus a judging panel that is so compromised that they won't have a complete vote on any building because of conflict of interests.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Simon  Quinlank

    Where's Central St Giles, btw?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Luke DC

    Time will tell, I agree with Simon they are not beautiful buildings. It seems Architecture or current Architects have been defeated as only affordable luxuries in good times, what a mess. I wonder how well Architects and Architecture are doing to prove useful in austerity times?. But to be positive they may have done very well with the budget and time frames they had. I just want to see beautiful buildings hopefully in 2012.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register
  • Email
  • Comments (7)
  • Save
Sign in

Email Newsletters

Sign out to login as another user

Desktop Site | Mobile Site